Ways to hire a (good) insurance agent:
- Advertising in the magazines which specifically relates to your cars (i.e. Camaro Magazine)
- Your local yellow pages always have many local and reliable agents, call around till you find the most reasonable rate or someone you want to work with.
- Seek out an agent that actively listens and asks relevant questions.
- Don't do business with someone you don't like or have a bad feel about.
- Get printouts of any proposal the agent offers.
- Deal only with an agent who finds you a policy you can afford & need.
- Don't take the first insurance agent you meet, unless you are still impressed after talking to several others.
- Contact at least five different agents. Consider using an insurance broker who can help you comparison shop.
- Ask for customer references and contact some of them to find out how they like the agent and their services.
- Measure how quickly an agent responds to your needs, compared to other agents.
| City | Agency Name | Contact | Phone |
| Bedford | State Farm Ins. | Larry Kidwell | 812-275-3811 |
| Beech Grove | Bruce's Enterprises | B. Rosemeyer | 317-784-7515 |
| Bloomington | American Family | Donald Patnode | 812-332-2700 |
| Carmel | Affordable Ins. | Robert Patterson | 317-867-1224 |
| Carmel | Allstate Ins. | RJ Puthran | 317-844-4683 |
| Clarksville | Aflac | Scott Rorrer | 502-645-7255 |
| Boise | Liability Solutions | Tannya Blackwood | 208-322-7770 |
| East Chicago | Nabors Ins. Agency | John Nabors | 219-398-6333 |
| Evansville | Vineyard Financial | Fred Forster | 812-474-6200 |
| Evansville | Independent Agent | Jeff Kleinschmidt | 812-479-9028 |
| Evansville | American General Ins. | C. Zirkelbach | 812-477-3450 |
| Evansville | The Ins. Shoppe, Inc. | Scott Furbee | 812-475-0100 |
| Evansville | Farmer's Ins. | Rick VanHoose | 812-401-4613 |
| Fort Wayne | Ousley Ins. | Ken Ousley | 260-478-9405 |
| Frankfort | AFLAC Ins. | Tina Fish | 765-296-8170 |
| Greencatle | Jason Wager Ins. | Jason Wager | 765-653-3743 |
| Greenwood | Benefit Marketing, Inc. | Thomas Weartz | 317-885-9105 |
| Indianapolis | United American | William Gray | 317-569-0495 |
| Indianapolis | MVP Ins. | Robert Tedder | 317-250-8126 |
| Indianapolis | AFLAC | Robert Tedder | 317-269-2654 |
| Indianapolis | Sagamore Benefits Group | Tom Ewigleben | 317-818-9700 |
| Indianapolis | Williams Ins. | Robert Williams | 317-823-3562 |
| Indianapolis | Mega Life & Health | Lisa Tuveri | 317-842-7511 |
| Indianapolis | Global Ins. | Mike Droll | 317-634-1525 |
| Indianapolis | Greenfield Ins. | Shunsuke Akagi | 317-496-4879 |
| Indianapolis | Metzinger | Anita Brewer | 317-849-2051 |
| Indianapolis | New Beginnings | Clarke Judd | 317-845-0690 |
| Indianapolis | Farmers Ins. | Robert Holocher | 317-241-6225 |
| Indianapolis | Chuck Schoolcraft | C. Schoolcraft | 317-356-0958 |
| Indianapolis | Wayne Barber | Wayne Barber | 317-787-7227 |
| Indianapolis | Herke Ins. Center | Philip Peterson | 317-251-7100 |
| Indianapolis | Senior Advisors Network | Jim Lowery | 317-255-5944 |
| Indianola | Weinman Ins. | Joe Weinman | 515-961-2567 |
| Kokomo | Nosek Ins. | Western & Southern | 765-513-9350 |
| Lafayette | Western Southern Life | Daniel Haines | 765-477-0201 |
| Lagrange | Nosek Ins. | Glynna L. Nosek | 219-463-8887 |
| Leesburg | Ins. Shoppe | Max Wysong | 574-453-3208 |
| Ligonier | Allstate Ins. | Robert Scott | 219-894-4423 |
| Michigan City | R.L. Geyer & Associates | Ron Geyer | 219-879-6062 |
| Mishawaka | The Sanders Agency | Larry Sanders | 219-254-2645 |
| Mishawaka | The Stohler Agency | AT Stohler | 219-259-2922 |
| Muncie | Senior Solutions | Daniel Harris | 765-289-1855 |
| Nappanee | Heckaman Shevely Ins. | John Paul Christner | 574-773-4231 |
| New Albany | AFLAC | Daniel Fabulic | 502-379-4191 |
| New Albany | Strawn Ins. Agency | Larry Nutter | 812-945-9934 |
| New Albany | Kentuckiana Group | Mark Nantz | 812-944-3200 |
| New Castle | Pfenninger Ins. Agency | Steve Pfenninger | 765-529-6400 |
| New Castle | Pfenninger Ins. Agency | Steve Pfenninger | 765-529-6400 |
| New Castle | Associated Ins. | Laura Hancock | 765-529-3030 |
| New Haven | American Family Ins. | Tracy Tutwiler | 219-749-7799 |
| Newburgh | State Farm Ins. | Larry Rhodes | 812-853-7301 |
| Newburgh | The Beem Agency | Randy Beem | 812-842-2336 |
| Peru | Semler Fianancial Group | Lisa Herron-Fields | 317-569-7600 |
| Portage | Central Ins. Agency | Benita Capps | 219-763-6145 |
| Rochester | Tracy Overmyer Ins. | Tracy Overmyer | 574-223-7483 |
| Rockport | American National | John Majewski | 812-649-0099 |
| Sellersburg | Cincinnati Insurance | Stephen Means | 812-786-9472 |
| Sellersburg | Kuehn Ins. Agency | Bill Kuehn | 812-246-3600 |
| South Bend | Mcdaniel Ins. Agency | Stefanie Mcdaniel | 574-299-1900 |
| South Bend | Farmers Ins. | John Majewski | 219-287-2100 |
| Terre Haute | Forrest Sherer | John Dinkel | 812-232-0441 |
| Terre Haute | Allstate Ins. | Bryan Sponsler | 812-466-4232 |
| Vevay | State Farm Ins. | Jennifer Scudder | 812-427-3434 |
|
